back to info and advice

Home birth v hospital birth

Blog Image

Ryansmummyuk, our guest blogger writes about home birth and water birth.

I've recently been browsing through the forums and have seen alot of questions on homebirths and/or water births. I had both, so I decided to do this blog about my experience, I hope it helps to awnser some of those questions!

Having a homebirth was not something I had ever thought of before getting pregnant. However, once I started to make plans for the birth, it made sense to me. I'm a severe needle phobic who is terrified of hospitals, and when in pain I like to be in familiar surroundings (you know when your ill and all you want to do is be in your own bed at home? Same kinda thing). My needle phobia is so severe I start hyperventilating if I see a yellow disposal bin, so you can imagine how bad a hospital makes me!

I did some research about it, read other peoples experiences and advise, medical pro's and con's etc then discussed it with my midwife and teenage pregnancy support worker. They said that if that was what I wanted they'd support me. My consultants however were not so supportive. Because I'd refused to have blood taken and I was a first-time teenage mum, they were dead set against it. When they realised they couldnt change my mind they finally agreed, after making me promise I'd come straight in if anything went wrong.

My midwife had to do a home visit to check how suitable my house was, things like accessibility and space. I was relieved that there was - I had a tiny 1 bedroom flat at the time. As I also wanted a waterbirth I researched birth pools, but my local hospital decided to buy some to rent out, and my teenage pregnancy support worker managed to persuade them to lend me one for free in exchange for feedback on it! Bonus!!! It was from BirthPool-In-A-Box, great price and good quality!

The day before my due date I thought my waters had broke. A community midwife was sent out to check but she wasnt sure, so on my due date I was taken into hospital. They said my waters were sealed, but they make have 'leaked'. I was monitored for a few hours, and was told I was 1cm dilated and contracting, but not strongly. I was then sent home to wait. Thank God!!! All I could think about whilst in one of their delivery suite rooms was god, I'm glad I'm not having my baby here. Dont get me wrong, it wasnt dirty or anything, just so clinical and cold.

6 days after my due date I went to bed crying, convinced my baby was never going to come out by himself. I woke at 5am with backache, so had a bath and went back to bed. I didnt even click this could be it! When I woke again at 9.30 I swung my legs outta bed and my waters went - there was no mistaking it this time! Then the contractions hit me. I shouted my friend who had been staying with me, and she called the midwife. The midwife asked to listen to me having a contractions - at the time I thought she was really weird but apparently a midwife can tell if your actually in labour by how you react on the phone during a contraction. Basically, if your still talking through them, you've got ages yet!!

I strapped on a TENS machine and crouched over the sofa, waiting for the midwife. When she arrived I was 3cm. My foster-mum and boyfriend arrived soon after. The midwife called for the second midwife to come (with gas and air) and my teenage pregnancy support worker run me a bath while my midwife and boyfriend set up the birth pool. Unfortunately, they forgot to put the splash mat down and blown up the bottom of the pool until after it was filling up with water, so I had to do without. The water itself was bliss, especially when they filled it with more hot water. I'd put the pipe to my back, it was so soothing. Once in the pool I only got out once for a wee, and refused to do it again! For me, the water made all the difference.

As for the home birth bit, it was very relaxed. I had barely any intervention, twice during my entire labour did they do an internal. For the most part everyone sat around having cups of tea and watching the Eastenders Omnibus. I ended up having my boyfriend, my foster-mum, my friend, her 7 month old, her dad, 2 midwifes and my teenage pregnancy support worker all in my flat. In addition to that, my friends car had been broken into a few days before, so her friend (who had 5 weeks left to go with her first) and her friends boyfriend were outside fixing it! I scared the hell out of the poor girl! As soon as I had given birth it was lovely to be able to lay in my own bed and cuddle my little boy. That first night I couldnt sleep, I sat up all night watching him.

However, there was a couple of things I struggled with. One was that its hard to take in information just after you've given birth, and that caused my next two problems. The midwifes will stay after the birth to deliver the placenta, do the APGAR and normally help clean up, but they will soon go. Once they were gone I had no-one to help me with breastfeeding, although they did try before they left. Also, if you have a homebirth you have to have the baby seen by a doctor between 24 and 48 hours. I cant remember whether my midwifes told me this, but I didnt absorb it, and only found out when he was 46 hours old. I had to make an emergency appt at the doctors and leg it down there... not fun when you've just given birth and its hurts to walk!!!!

So - I'd highly recommend a homebirth/waterbirth. It was an amazing experience, I was very comfortable and relaxed in my own enviroment. It just felt so natural. However, I did live 5 minutes from the nearest hospital, and had anything gone wrong I wouldnt have hesitated to go there. The thing to remember with any kind of birth plan is you can plan all you want, but baby might have other ideas, and the most important thing is to get baby out safely however you have to do it.

comments

(16)

  • I didnt even consider Having a home birth with my daughter! But i would love one this time, although i dont think id be able to because of my pre-eclampsia :(

    by BeckiAndEmma 18 April 2010

  • I'd have loved a home birth in a pool, although i would not have been able to handle not having an ep and the help of all those nurses with the complications with my birth

    by DarceyMyLove 17 April 2010

  • i wanted a home birth i would feel more calmer i thought buh i had to have eidural and forceps due to health reasons

    by XkirstyX 14 April 2010

  • i'd planning a water birth with this baby at the moment, my second child :) i'm quite excited for the experience!

    by rosiealford 13 April 2010

  • Hospital Birth... I f something goes wrong while your at home what are you meant to do!! Hospitals have more stuff at the ready xx

    by Jadeyy 6 April 2010

  • I wanted to have my birth in hospital as i am a crazy panic-er! an wen i was in early stages of labour the bath really did nothing for me, i couldnt relax at all. plus i had to go into hospital as i was running a crazy temperature, kept being sick, an it hurt for me to pass urine! ahh is childbirth glamourous! lol x

    by kerry 31 March 2010

  • @xlauraxgx - Do you mean do you have to pay for them? No, you dont hun xxx

    by ryansmummyuk 29 March 2010

  • i wanted a water birth at hospital but didnt get one as my son pooed in my waters lol but i did have him at hosp i was too scared at home and wanted to go in straight away x

    by YummyMummyJD 25 March 2010

  • i would like a water birth in the hospital but do u have 2 oay 4 them ? x

    by 23 March 2010

  • @Smarties - you dont need to be in hospital 2 have stitches, they can do them at a homebirth. Thanks guys! Alot of midwifes/consultants are very reluctant to let young first time mums have homebirths, and its still quite a rarety and something I would have never thought of before getting pregnant, but actually its been proved the pain rate is lower when you are relaxed in your own surroundings, labour tends to progress more naturally and its less stressful after the birth. Thanks @Earthmummy - I wasnt giving it without a fight! Midwifes etc cannot refuse you a homebirth.... they can advise against it but they do have to spend someone out when you go into labour. I also forgot to recommend you have someone stay with your for a few days after the birth, just to help out, make sure you eat etc. I do wish to stress though that sometimes home births are dangerous (if you have complications etc) and if you dont get the birth you wanted please dont be dissapointed - so long as baby arrives healthy that is absoloutely all that matters!

    by ryansmummyuk 17 March 2010

  • I wanted a home water birth but thought it would be safer to be in hospital just in case and im glad i did as my son weighed 9lb 2oz and i had to have stitches :)

    by Smarties 13 March 2010

  • I am so lucky to have a supportive midwife. she suggested to me yesterday the idea of a home&water birth.... she said that women aged 14-18 bodies are the perfect age for having babies... despite what the media says. and like yourself, i live pretty near to the hospital. i just don't want to get to the hospital and the birthing pools to be taken. she also said, worst ways if i did want to go to hospital in the end i could do. completely up to me. i'm so glad i've read someone's personal experience on the both! I think i am definitely leaning towards a home/water birth.

    by Georgia91 5 March 2010

  • I would like to try a homebirth, but i'm not planning anymore children lol! I would be scared to aswell because I had to have a forceps delivery with my first and had problems after the birth with my 2nd. I suppose with tegan i would have had her at home and just had to go in afterwards but i would probably have been twice as upset then!

    by LittleMumma 5 March 2010

  • Thanks for sharing this... Really useful!

    by mumpreneur 5 March 2010

  • Statistics are stupid :p Ryansmummy - I am so glad you got the birth you wanted. I would have loved a home birth, but my hospital lied to me and said I 'wasnt allowed' a home birth due to my disability. Having since researched it more thoroughly, my next baby is arriving at home (unless there is a medical emergency). due to unnecessary intervention, my labour ended up being over 24 hours and ended with an emergency section. If they'd left me at home with my birthing ball, where I was progressing fine, I would have had him in half that Well done for not being put off by the consultants :)

    by Earthmummy 4 March 2010

  • @Ryansmummyuk your story was really helpful - I, like yourself had never considered a water birth until I read a book on hospital birth and really put me off - how they time your labour etc and how you culd end up having intervention you may not necesarily need. I think that it should be more of an option women are made aware of instead of them stumbling accross it by chace. Didn't know if you already knew this but the statistics for the death rate of baby and mother for home birth but a home birth consists of anything out of hospital so it could be a women who has gone into premature labour and not got to hospital in time if her baby or her was to die then it would be classed as a statistic for home birth!! xx

    by KittyBoo 4 March 2010